Animal Rights and Vegan Advocacy
PUBLIC BETA SITE

Situational Objections Section

Reasoned responses, organized as talking points, to common objections, concerns, and questions regarding animal rights and veganism.

Filter on title and article text (title matches will appear emboldened):
“I can’t afford to be vegan—it’s too expensive.”“i can’t afford to be vegan—it’s too expensive.”“i can’t afford to be vegan—it’s too expensive.”[toc label="talking points"]some have claimed that going vegan is expensive and, for some, unaffordable. the implication is that eating a vegan diet is a luxury that only the affluent can afford.

vegan diets are usually less expensive.

if you continue eating the same amount of fruit and greens but replace your meat with staples such as potatoes, beans, rice, oats, and corn, then it's hard to see how you would spend more.mayo clinic considers lower costs to be one of the benefits of meatless meals. in stating that meatless meals are budget friendly and can be used to save money, they add that some plant-based proteins "tend to be less expensive and offer more health benefits than meat."((“it’s time to try meatless meals.” mayo clinic, july 26, 2017. http://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/in-depth/meatless-meals/art-20048193 ))registered dietitian ginny messina confirms, "replacing the meat, dairy, and eggs in diets with lower cost foods like grains, beans and tofu isn’t just frugal, it’s much more healthful."((messina, ginny. “the high cost of ethical eating.” the vegan rd, january 20, 2010. http://www.theveganrd.com/2010/01/the-high-cost-of-ethical-eating/ ))research bears this out. a study published in the journal of hunger and environmental nutrition concludes that even an economic version of a government-recommended meal plan costs $745 more per year than a plant-based meal plan and provides "fewer servings of vegetables, fruits, and whole grains."((flynn, mary m., and andrew r. schiff. “economical healthy diets (2012): including lean animal protein costs more than using extra virgin olive oil.” journal of hunger & environmental nutrition 10, no. 4 (october 2, 2015): 467–82. doi:10.1080/19320248.2015.1045675 ))

many foods cost the same.

you may be surprised to find that many common foods in the grocery store are already vegan and, consequently, your costs for these items won't go up.these include everything in the produce department, all bulk items (except jerky), most cereals, most breads, all grains and beans, most canned and frozen fruits and vegetables, most condiments, such as mustard, ketchup, pickles, relish, and sauces, and virtually all spices.

vegan specialty foods are optional.

some vegan items, such as burger patties and mayonnaise, are no more expensive. vegan milks cost no more than organic, hormone-free cow's milk. vegan cheeses and meats can be more expensive but are becoming less expensive as demand increases.prepared foods will almost always cost more, vegan or not, and many of these foods you can make yourself for considerably less.all of these processed foods are optional—you can choose to just leave them off the menu.

your medical bills may decrease.

a study published by the national academy of sciences calculates a health-care savings of over $1,067 billion annually with a vegan diet.((springmann, marco, h. charles j. godfray, mike rayner, and peter scarborough. “analysis and valuation of the health and climate change co-benefits of dietary change.” proceedings of the national academy of sciences 113, no. 15 (april 12, 2016): 4146–51. doi:10.1073/pnas.1523119113 )) that's over $3,000 for each person in the united states. the savings are a result of less medical care needed because medical problems are less likely on a vegan diet.

consider the cost to animals.

we are often willing to pay more for convenience. we are often willing to pay more for items that have a smaller carbon footprint. we are often willing to pay more for designer items.eating vegan is not more expensive. but even if it were, shouldn't we be willing to pay more for items that don't support, directly or indirectly, the breeding, enslavement, mutilation, and slaughter of sentient beings who have lives that are as important to them as our lives are to us?

here are some tips for saving on groceries.

here are a few tips for saving on your grocery bill:
  • buy in bulk and at farmer's markets.
  • shop seasonally.
  • buy vegetables frozen, since they often cost less and are just as healthy.
  • compare prices. a pound of green peas costs around $1.30 at walmart, trader joe's, and whole foods market. the same pound of peas can be as high as $3.00 at other grocery stores.
  • limit specialty foods, such as vegan meats and cheeses. they are unnecessary. while they may be more healthy than animal-based meats and cheeses, they are not as healthy as whole foods.
“There are no true vegans. Animal products are in car tires and everywhere.”“there are no true vegans. animal products are in car tires and everywhere.”“there are no true vegans. animal products are in car tires and everywhere.”[toc label="talking points"] some have objected to veganism on the grounds that there are no true or pure vegans by virtue of the widespread inclusion of animal-derived products in many everyday items. this complaint, at best, reveals a lack of understanding about the definition and essence of veganism. at worst, it is an attempt to apply standards to veganism that would not be applied to any other cause or movement.

vegans seek to minimize harm to animals, not be perfect.

vegans seek to eliminate harm to animals, according to the most widely accepted definition of veganism, "as far as is possible and practicable." there are some items containing incidental amounts of animal products for which there are no viable substitutes or for which substitutes are very difficult to obtain. automobile tires are one such example.this situation is beyond our control in the short term. it would be nonsensible to say that because we can't be perfect vegans, we shouldn't do anything. with the wide variety of fruits, vegetables, grains, legumes, nuts, and seeds available to most—as well as an increasingly large selection of processed vegan foods—it is not at all logistically difficult for most to adopt a vegan diet. adopting a vegan diet would eliminate, by far, most of the unnecessary suffering and slaughter that we pay others to inflict on animals.

once we stop eating animals, other uses will be eliminated or greatly reduced.

the incidental use of animals in everyday products will take care of itself as veganism gains acceptance and people adopt a vegan diet. many of the products used, for which there are already alternatives, are byproducts of the slaughter process. as animal slaughter becomes less commonplace, nonanimal substitutes will be used and new substitutes will be developed.

no one objects to other worthy causes just because perfection is unobtainable.

it would be difficult to think of any movement or cause in which perfection is obtainable. no one would say that because we will never completely stop discrimination, we shouldn't try to do what we can. no one would say that because we will never stop child abuse completely that we shouldn't even try. no one would say, for any worthwhile cause, that if we can't do everything, we shouldn't do anything. it seems disingenuous to apply such a standard of purity or perfection to veganism while ignoring it for other causes.
“It’s OK to eat animals that have been treated welI. I only eat certified humane, pasture-raised, cage-free, free-range products.” To Do“it's ok to eat animals that have been treated weli. i only eat certified humane, pasture-raised, cage-free, free-range products.” to do“it’s ok to eat animals that have been treated weli. i only eat certified humane, pasture-raised, cage-free, free-range products.” to do
“If I’m stuck on a small island, I may have to eat meat to survive.” To Do“if i’m stuck on a small island, i may have to eat meat to survive.” to do“if i’m stuck on a small island, i may have to eat meat to survive.” to do
“The Eskimo/Inuit don’t have good plant options. And BTW, they’re healthy ” To Do“the eskimo/inuit don’t have good plant options. and btw, they’re healthy ” to do“the eskimo/inuit don’t have good plant options. and btw, they’re healthy ” to do
“Some vegans would save a dog from a burning house before saving a human.” To Do“some vegans would save a dog from a burning house before saving a human.” to do“some vegans would save a dog from a burning house before saving a human.” to do
“Eating animals is our heritage and tradition” To Do“eating animals is our heritage and tradition” to do“eating animals is our heritage and tradition” to do
“Vegans are extreme, self-righteous, judgemental, and angry.” To Do“vegans are extreme, self-righteous, judgemental, and angry.” to do“vegans are extreme, self-righteous, judgemental, and angry.” to do
?>