To get updates on new site content, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.

Difference between revisions of "Assignment:Vegan Diets"

From JFA Wiki
(→‎= Omega 3's)
 
(28 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 5: Line 5:
 
{{jfa-note-end}}
 
{{jfa-note-end}}
  
−
<-- Visible editorial notes appear between ''<--'' and ''-->'' tags. You can delete them after you start on a section or you can hide them by using the standard notation for [https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Help:Comment_tags comments], adding an exclamation mark:  <nowiki>"<!-- note goes here -->."</nowiki> They should be deleted, hidden or not, before the pre-publication review. The author should delete this particular one after reading it. -->
+
<-- Visible editorial notes appear between ''<--'' and ''-->'' tags. You can delete them after you start on a section or you can hide them by using the standard notation for [https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Help:Comment_tags comments], adding an exclamation mark:  <nowiki>"<!-- note goes here -->."</nowiki> They should be deleted, hidden or not, before the pre-publication review. The author should delete this particular one after reading it. -->
  
 
== Introduction ==
 
== Introduction ==
  
−
A vegan diet is one in which no animal products are consumed. While those embracing veganism are consequently on a vegan diet, a vegan diet is not synonymous with veganism, which is more generally a way of living that avoids the exploitation of animals as far as possible and practicable. Also, the phrase ''vegan diet'' refers to a dietary pattern, and not a programmatic diet such as the South Beach Diet.
+
A vegan diet is one in which no animal products are consumed. While those embracing veganism are by definition on a vegan diet, a vegan diet is not synonymous with veganism, which is more generally a way of living that avoids the exploitation of animals as far as possible and practicable. Also, the phrase ''vegan diet'' refers to a dietary pattern, and not a programmatic diet such as the South Beach Diet.
  
 
== Types of Vegan Diets ==
 
== Types of Vegan Diets ==
Line 27: Line 27:
  
 
While the categories above may be thought of as general patterns, there are other vegan diets that are more prescriptive, such as the 90/10/10 Diet, the Starch Solutions Diet, and the Thrive Diet.
 
While the categories above may be thought of as general patterns, there are other vegan diets that are more prescriptive, such as the 90/10/10 Diet, the Starch Solutions Diet, and the Thrive Diet.
−
<-- if you wish, modify or briefly discuss further -->
 
  
 
== Overall Benefits ==
 
== Overall Benefits ==
Line 39: Line 38:
 
{{jfa-note-end}}
 
{{jfa-note-end}}
  
−
<--Discuss. Appeal to the expertise of organizations, not individuals. As summarized as possible, invoke the positions or words of Harvard Public Health, Cleveland Clinic, Mayo Clinic, Kaiser Permanente, but more importantly, and the Dietetic Associations of US, Canada, Great Britian, and Australia to support the contention that vegan diets go beyond adequate and are advantageous. It's good to mention specific diseases these organizations mention, but save the details on each for the next section.
+
<--Discuss. Appeal to the expertise of organizations, not individuals. As summarized as possible, invoke the positions or words of Harvard Public Health, Cleveland Clinic, Mayo Clinic, Kaiser Permanente, but more importantly, and the Dietetic Associations of US, Canada, Great Britian, and Australia to support the contention that vegan diets go beyond adequate and are advantageous. It's good to mention specific diseases these organizations mention, but save the details on each for the next section. -->
−
 
+
 
<--Similar treatments on this site can be found [[In reply to: We need animal products to be healthy#Talking_Points | here]] and [[In reply to: Humans are natural omnivores; we digest meat, have canine teeth, and have front-facing eyes | here]]. -->
 
<--Similar treatments on this site can be found [[In reply to: We need animal products to be healthy#Talking_Points | here]] and [[In reply to: Humans are natural omnivores; we digest meat, have canine teeth, and have front-facing eyes | here]]. -->
  
 
=== Studies on General Health ===
 
=== Studies on General Health ===
  
−
<-- Briefly discuss population and other studies that show the overall health benefits of a vegan diet. -->
+
We discuss the benefits of a vegan diet to mitigate or reverse several chronic diseases and conditions below, but here we briefly point out some overall benefits of a vegan diet.
 +
 
 +
<-- Briefly discuss population and other studies that show the ''overall'' health benefits of a vegan diet. -->
 +
 
 +
<-- suggestions:
 +
* Longevity
 +
* Athletic strength, endurance, and recovery times
 +
-->
  
 
=== Why Plant Foods are Advantageous ===
 
=== Why Plant Foods are Advantageous ===
Line 59: Line 65:
 
This section discusses specific conditions that could likely be mitigated or eliminated by adopting a vegan diet. As you might expect, the benefits will be greater to whatever extent you eat plant-based whole foods instead of vegan junk foods.
 
This section discusses specific conditions that could likely be mitigated or eliminated by adopting a vegan diet. As you might expect, the benefits will be greater to whatever extent you eat plant-based whole foods instead of vegan junk foods.
  
−
Because testimonials are anecdotal, we don't include them in the sections below for each of these conditions. However, the stories of real people can be informing and inspiring. You can find an abundance of these testimonials with a Google search, or more specifically at [https://nutritionstudies.org/topics/success-stories/ The Center for Nutrition Studies]<ref>“Success Stories,” Center for Nutrition Studies (blog), accessed October 3, 2019, https://nutritionstudies.org/topics/success-stories/.</ref>, [https://www.forksoverknives.com/success-stories Forks Over Knives]<ref>“Plant-Based Diet Success Stories,” Forks Over Knives, accessed October 3, 2019, https://www.forksoverknives.com/success-stories/</ref>, and [https://nutriciously.com/vegan-transformation/ Nutriciously]<ref>“14 Vegan Transformation Stories That Make You Want to Eat More Plants,” Nutriciously (blog), March 5, 2018, https://nutriciously.com/vegan-transformation/</ref>. If you would rather hear physicians discuss what plant-based diets have done for their patients, watch the YouTube video [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QN7dCN5CCsM ''Revealed: Dramatic Health Reversals Eating Plant-Based''].<ref>“YouTube.” Accessed October 15, 2019. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QN7dCN5CCsM</ref>
+
<-- There will be a separate, more detailed article for each of the conditions below, so in this article we want to provide the best, most convincing evidence, but highly summarized. Then, as these other articles are written, we will edit this article to add links such as "additional details can be found at ...."  The same can be said for the other sections after this Health Benefits section --
  
 
<--There is an article similar to this one at https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/vegan-diet-guide. This article presents numerous citations that could save a lot of time running down studies and sources. There may be other studies that are more convincing, valid, and definitive, in which case those other sources should be used.-->
 
<--There is an article similar to this one at https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/vegan-diet-guide. This article presents numerous citations that could save a lot of time running down studies and sources. There may be other studies that are more convincing, valid, and definitive, in which case those other sources should be used.-->
−
 
−
<-- There will be a separate, more detailed article for each of the conditions below, so in this article we want to provide the best, most convincing evidence, but highly summarized. Then, as these other articles are written, we will edit this article to add links such as "additional details can be found at ...."  The same can be said for the other sections after this Health Benefits section -->
 
  
 
=== Obesity ===
 
=== Obesity ===
Line 88: Line 92:
 
=== Osteoporosis ===
 
=== Osteoporosis ===
 
<-- briefly, keeping in mind a separate article on the topic is forthcoming  -->
 
<-- briefly, keeping in mind a separate article on the topic is forthcoming  -->
 +
 +
=== Macular Degeneration ===
 +
<-- briefly, keeping in mind a separate article on the topic is forthcoming  -->
 +
 +
=== Chronic Pain ===
 +
 +
<-- briefly, keeping in mind a separate article on the topic is forthcoming  -->
 +
<-- Neal Barnard did a video on this -->
  
 
=== ?Condition XXX? (or delete this heading) ===
 
=== ?Condition XXX? (or delete this heading) ===
Line 98: Line 110:
  
 
Other conditions which may be mitigated by a vegan diet, but for which the studies are not as numerous or conclusive as the ones reported above, include <-- condition-aaa[n][n]?, condition-bbb[n][n][n], and condition-ccc[n]. -->
 
Other conditions which may be mitigated by a vegan diet, but for which the studies are not as numerous or conclusive as the ones reported above, include <-- condition-aaa[n][n]?, condition-bbb[n][n][n], and condition-ccc[n]. -->
 +
 +
== Testimonials ==
 +
 +
Because testimonials are anecdotal, we don't include them in the sections aove for each of these conditions covered. However, the stories of real people can be informing and inspiring. You can find an abundance of these testimonials with a Google search, or more specifically at [https://nutritionstudies.org/topics/success-stories/ The Center for Nutrition Studies]<ref>“Success Stories,” Center for Nutrition Studies (blog), accessed October 3, 2019, https://nutritionstudies.org/topics/success-stories/.</ref>, [https://www.forksoverknives.com/success-stories Forks Over Knives]<ref>“Plant-Based Diet Success Stories,” Forks Over Knives, accessed October 3, 2019, https://www.forksoverknives.com/success-stories/</ref>, and [https://nutriciously.com/vegan-transformation/ Nutriciously]<ref>“14 Vegan Transformation Stories That Make You Want to Eat More Plants,” Nutriciously (blog), March 5, 2018, https://nutriciously.com/vegan-transformation/</ref>. If you would rather hear physicians discuss what plant-based diets have done for their patients, watch the YouTube video [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QN7dCN5CCsM ''Revealed: Dramatic Health Reversals Eating Plant-Based''].<ref>“YouTube.” Accessed October 15, 2019. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QN7dCN5CCsM</ref>
  
 
== Nutrient Concerns and Supplementation ==
 
== Nutrient Concerns and Supplementation ==
Line 105: Line 121:
 
Regarding supplementation, keep in mind that taking unneeded supplements can result in health risks<ref>Novick, MS, RD, LD, LN, Jeff. “Q &amp; A’s.” JEFF NOVICK. Accessed August 9, 2018. https://jeffnovick.com/RD/Q_&amp;_As/Entries/2012/10/18_Supplements.html </ref>, so it's a good idea to get a professional diagnosis for any suspected nutrient deficiency.
 
Regarding supplementation, keep in mind that taking unneeded supplements can result in health risks<ref>Novick, MS, RD, LD, LN, Jeff. “Q &amp; A’s.” JEFF NOVICK. Accessed August 9, 2018. https://jeffnovick.com/RD/Q_&amp;_As/Entries/2012/10/18_Supplements.html </ref>, so it's a good idea to get a professional diagnosis for any suspected nutrient deficiency.
  
−
There seems to be general agreement that vegans should supplement with Vitamin B12. In our [[In reply to: B12 is a problem for vegans, so a vegan diet is not natural | reply to objections regarding B12]], we convey recommendations for supplementation, show that B12 supplementation is inexpensive, and show that vegans' need for B12 supplementation should not be used to draw conclusions about a vegan diet not being natural or optimal.
+
The idea that we need any animal products to be healthy is shown to be false in our [[In reply to: We need animal products to be healthy | reply to that notion]]. The nutrients covered below are ones that some have said could be problem for vegans. The bottom line is that science knows of no nutrient that cannot be easily obtained without difficulty in sufficient quantities for good health—outside the animal kingdom.
  
−
The idea that we need animal products to be healthy is shown to be false in our  [[In reply to: We need animal products to be healthy | reply to that notion]]. Protein is covered [[In reply to: Protein is a problem for vegans|here]] and there will be additional articles on the JFA Wiki covering specific nutrients of concern such as Omega 3's and Calcium.
+
=== Protein ===
  
−
The bottom line is that science knows of no nutrient that cannot be easily obtained without difficulty in sufficient quantities for good health—outside the animal kingdom.
+
In our  [[In reply to: Protein is a problem for vegans | reply ]] the notion that protein is a problem for vegans, we show that plants readily supply abundant and complete protein and that a protein deficiency is almost always associated with a calorie deficiency—if you get sufficient calories a protein deficiency is unlikely.
  
−
=== Protein ===
+
=== Vitamin B12 ===
 +
 
 +
There seems to be general agreement that vegans should supplement with Vitamin B12. In our [[In reply to: B12 is a problem for vegans, so a vegan diet is not natural | reply to objections regarding B12]], we discuss dosage recommendations, show that B12 supplementation is inexpensive, and show that vegans' need for B12 supplementation should not be used to draw conclusions about a vegan diet not being natural or optimal.
 +
 
 +
<-- Because separate articles are planned for each of the following nutrients, discuss as succinctly and briefly as possible how each of the following nutrients relate to a vegan diet. This might include answers to the following questions:
 +
 
 +
— Are vegans at risk for a deficiency of this nutrient?
 +
— Is supplementation needed, and if so, under what conditions?
 +
— If we need this nutrient and our bodies can't make it, what are good plant sources for the nutrient?
  
−
=== Vitamin B12 ===
+
-->
  
−
=== Vitamin D ===
+
=== Vitamin D3 ===
  
−
=== Omega 3's ===
+
=== Omega 3's / DHA ===
  
 
=== Iodine ===
 
=== Iodine ===
Line 126: Line 150:
  
 
=== Zinc ===
 
=== Zinc ===
 +
 +
=== K12 ===
 +
 +
=== Choline ===
 +
 +
=== Taurine ===
 +
                                     
 +
=== Creatine ===
 +
 +
=== Carnosine ===
  
 
== Getting Started ==
 
== Getting Started ==
Line 136: Line 170:
  
 
[https://youtu.be/wOrNpVDNhJw  How to Do a Vegan Diet Right] • A YouTube video by Dr. Steven Lome.
 
[https://youtu.be/wOrNpVDNhJw  How to Do a Vegan Diet Right] • A YouTube video by Dr. Steven Lome.
−
<-- Feel free to add some evidence-based outside sources that seem particularly apt to you. --:>
+
 
 +
<-- Add some other evidence-based outside sources that seem particularly apt to you. --:>
  
 
== Footnotes ==
 
== Footnotes ==
Line 164: Line 199:
 
-->
 
-->
  
−
<-- This assignment contains text to be included in the article, which are not editorial notes, and which will not count as words contributed by the author -->
+
<-- This assignment contains text to be included in the article, which are not editorial notes, and which will not count as words contributed by the author for payment purposes -->

Latest revision as of 20:41, 30 October 2020

This assignment is a work in process and not ready to be assigned. Assignments are moved to the draft namespace after an author has accepted the assignment.

<-- Visible editorial notes appear between <-- and --> tags. You can delete them after you start on a section or you can hide them by using the standard notation for comments, adding an exclamation mark: "<!-- note goes here -->." They should be deleted, hidden or not, before the pre-publication review. The author should delete this particular one after reading it. -->

Introduction

A vegan diet is one in which no animal products are consumed. While those embracing veganism are by definition on a vegan diet, a vegan diet is not synonymous with veganism, which is more generally a way of living that avoids the exploitation of animals as far as possible and practicable. Also, the phrase vegan diet refers to a dietary pattern, and not a programmatic diet such as the South Beach Diet.

Types of Vegan Diets

Vegan diets vary greatly, and those following a vegan diet usually do not adhere strictly to one of the categories of the vegan diet discussed below. Also, most of the pertinent research regarding diets does not distinguish between the categories. Still, these categories are useful for discussion.

Whole-Food Plant-Based

<-- explain what it is and briefly discuss -->

Raw Diet

<-- explain what it is and briefly discuss -->

Junk Food Vegan Diet

<-- explain what it is and briefly discuss -->

Others

While the categories above may be thought of as general patterns, there are other vegan diets that are more prescriptive, such as the 90/10/10 Diet, the Starch Solutions Diet, and the Thrive Diet.

Overall Benefits

Scientific Consensus

There are no governing bodies that vote on a particular scientific position that would declare the position to reach the level of scientific consensus. However, a strong argument could be made, and is made below, that there is a scientific consensus that a vegan diet is not only adequate for good health, but also nutritionally advantageous over other dietary patterns. This is because scientists specializing in the field of nutrition generally agree.

Scientific consensus is a position "generally agreed upon at a given time by most scientists specialized in a given field". It does not represent unanimity, as some scientists in the field may disagree.[1]

<--Discuss. Appeal to the expertise of organizations, not individuals. As summarized as possible, invoke the positions or words of Harvard Public Health, Cleveland Clinic, Mayo Clinic, Kaiser Permanente, but more importantly, and the Dietetic Associations of US, Canada, Great Britian, and Australia to support the contention that vegan diets go beyond adequate and are advantageous. It's good to mention specific diseases these organizations mention, but save the details on each for the next section. -->

<--Similar treatments on this site can be found here and here. -->

Studies on General Health

We discuss the benefits of a vegan diet to mitigate or reverse several chronic diseases and conditions below, but here we briefly point out some overall benefits of a vegan diet.

<-- Briefly discuss population and other studies that show the overall health benefits of a vegan diet. -->

<-- suggestions:

  • Longevity
  • Athletic strength, endurance, and recovery times

-->

Why Plant Foods are Advantageous

<-- Briefly discuss the reasons vegan diets are advantageous, such as fiber, phytonutrients, etc. -->

Why Animal Products are Harmful

<-- Briefly discuss why animal products are harmful, such as animal protein, saturated fat, and cholesterol. Also mention our herbivorous anatomy and physiology and link to Table: The Comparative Anatomy of Eating and/or In reply to: Humans are natural omnivores; we digest meat, have canine teeth, and have front-facing eyes -->

Diseases and Disorders

This section discusses specific conditions that could likely be mitigated or eliminated by adopting a vegan diet. As you might expect, the benefits will be greater to whatever extent you eat plant-based whole foods instead of vegan junk foods.

<-- There will be a separate, more detailed article for each of the conditions below, so in this article we want to provide the best, most convincing evidence, but highly summarized. Then, as these other articles are written, we will edit this article to add links such as "additional details can be found at ...." The same can be said for the other sections after this Health Benefits section --

<--There is an article similar to this one at https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/vegan-diet-guide. This article presents numerous citations that could save a lot of time running down studies and sources. There may be other studies that are more convincing, valid, and definitive, in which case those other sources should be used.-->

Obesity

<-- briefly, keeping in mind a separate article on the topic is forthcoming -->

Diabetes

<-- briefly, keeping in mind a separate article on the topic is forthcoming -->

Heart Disease and Hypertension

<-- briefly, keeping in mind a separate article on the topic is forthcoming -->

Cancer

<-- briefly, keeping in mind a separate article on the topic is forthcoming -->

Arthritis

<-- briefly, keeping in mind a separate article on the topic is forthcoming -->

Kidney Disease

<-- briefly, keeping in mind a separate article on the topic is forthcoming -->

Alzheimer's

<-- briefly, keeping in mind a separate article on the topic is forthcoming -->

Osteoporosis

<-- briefly, keeping in mind a separate article on the topic is forthcoming -->

Macular Degeneration

<-- briefly, keeping in mind a separate article on the topic is forthcoming -->

Chronic Pain

<-- briefly, keeping in mind a separate article on the topic is forthcoming --> <-- Neal Barnard did a video on this -->

?Condition XXX? (or delete this heading)

<-- briefly, keeping in mind a separate article on the topic is forthcoming -->

?Condition YYY, etc? (or delete this heading)

<-- briefly, keeping in mind a separate article on the topic is forthcoming -->

Other Conditions

Other conditions which may be mitigated by a vegan diet, but for which the studies are not as numerous or conclusive as the ones reported above, include <-- condition-aaa[n][n]?, condition-bbb[n][n][n], and condition-ccc[n]. -->

Testimonials

Because testimonials are anecdotal, we don't include them in the sections aove for each of these conditions covered. However, the stories of real people can be informing and inspiring. You can find an abundance of these testimonials with a Google search, or more specifically at The Center for Nutrition Studies[2], Forks Over Knives[3], and Nutriciously[4]. If you would rather hear physicians discuss what plant-based diets have done for their patients, watch the YouTube video Revealed: Dramatic Health Reversals Eating Plant-Based.[5]

Nutrient Concerns and Supplementation

We should all be vigilant about meeting our nutritional requirements no matter what our eating pattern, but the sometimes near-obsessive level of concern about specific deficiencies of a vegan diet are unwarranted. Vegans can, of course, be deficient in one or more nutrients, as can others. The U.S. Dietary Guidelines reveal that most Americans are deficient in seven nutrients: calcium, potassium, fiber, magnesium, vitamin A, vitamin C, and vitamin E.[6]

Regarding supplementation, keep in mind that taking unneeded supplements can result in health risks[7], so it's a good idea to get a professional diagnosis for any suspected nutrient deficiency.

The idea that we need any animal products to be healthy is shown to be false in our reply to that notion. The nutrients covered below are ones that some have said could be problem for vegans. The bottom line is that science knows of no nutrient that cannot be easily obtained without difficulty in sufficient quantities for good health—outside the animal kingdom.

Protein

In our reply the notion that protein is a problem for vegans, we show that plants readily supply abundant and complete protein and that a protein deficiency is almost always associated with a calorie deficiency—if you get sufficient calories a protein deficiency is unlikely.

Vitamin B12

There seems to be general agreement that vegans should supplement with Vitamin B12. In our reply to objections regarding B12, we discuss dosage recommendations, show that B12 supplementation is inexpensive, and show that vegans' need for B12 supplementation should not be used to draw conclusions about a vegan diet not being natural or optimal.

<-- Because separate articles are planned for each of the following nutrients, discuss as succinctly and briefly as possible how each of the following nutrients relate to a vegan diet. This might include answers to the following questions:

— Are vegans at risk for a deficiency of this nutrient? — Is supplementation needed, and if so, under what conditions? — If we need this nutrient and our bodies can't make it, what are good plant sources for the nutrient?

-->

Vitamin D3

Omega 3's / DHA

Iodine

Iron

Calcium

Zinc

K12

Choline

Taurine

Creatine

Carnosine

Getting Started

See our Getting Started with Going Vegan article for 12 tips to help you get started. In addition, our Helpful Resources table lists a number of websites, including two that have excellent sections on recipes—Forks Over Knives and The Center For Nutrition Studies. Also, you can find a list of starter kits and help sites here.

Finally, to repeat our getting started article, many have found leaving animals off the plate to be an adventure, discovering new foods, recipes, and tastes they have never before experienced. Like many changes, being vegan will soon be second nature.

See Also

How to Do a Vegan Diet Right • A YouTube video by Dr. Steven Lome.

<-- Add some other evidence-based outside sources that seem particularly apt to you. --:>

Footnotes

  1. ↑ “Glossary: Scientific Consensus,” accessed October 2, 2019, http://www.greenfacts.org/glossary/abc/consensus.htm.
  2. ↑ “Success Stories,” Center for Nutrition Studies (blog), accessed October 3, 2019, https://nutritionstudies.org/topics/success-stories/.
  3. ↑ “Plant-Based Diet Success Stories,” Forks Over Knives, accessed October 3, 2019, https://www.forksoverknives.com/success-stories/
  4. ↑ “14 Vegan Transformation Stories That Make You Want to Eat More Plants,” Nutriciously (blog), March 5, 2018, https://nutriciously.com/vegan-transformation/
  5. ↑ “YouTube.” Accessed October 15, 2019. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QN7dCN5CCsM
  6. ↑ needs citation
  7. ↑ Novick, MS, RD, LD, LN, Jeff. “Q & A’s.” JEFF NOVICK. Accessed August 9, 2018. https://jeffnovick.com/RD/Q_&_As/Entries/2012/10/18_Supplements.html

Meta

This article was originally authored by ???, with contributions by Greg Fuller. The contents may have been edited since that time by others.

<--Other Editorial Notes

  • What have I left out? * Does there need to be additional sections, or maybe another structure is better; this is not written in stone—ping your editor. *
  • There is an article similar to this one at https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/vegan-diet-guide. This article presents numerous citations that could save a lot of time running down studies and sources. There may be other valid studies that are more convincing, valid, and definitive, in which case those other sources should be used.
  • The following is not the responsibility of the author but could be done by the author. It is put here as a reminder:
    • After this article is complete, a search needs to be made of the phrase "vegan diet" and these phrases need to be linked to this article with "[[Vegan Diet | vegan diet]]".

-->

<-- This assignment contains text to be included in the article, which are not editorial notes, and which will not count as words contributed by the author for payment purposes -->

Retrieved from "https://justiceforanimals.org/index.php?title=Assignment:Vegan_Diets&oldid=6828"