Difference between revisions of "Grass Fed"
Greg.Fuller (talk | contribs) |
Greg.Fuller (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== Summary == | == Summary == | ||
| − | Animal products packaged with a generic ''grass-fed'' label are often thought to represent a better life for animals, a smaller footprint for our planet, and a healthier alternative for human consumption. But as shown below, any claims for animal welfare are | + | Animal products packaged with a generic ''grass-fed'' label are often thought to represent a better life for animals, a smaller footprint for our planet, and a healthier alternative for human consumption. But as shown below, any claims for animal welfare are meaningless for the generic label, and the claims for sustainability and better health are highly questionable. |
| − | In 2016, the USDA | + | In 2016, the USDA stopped regulating the label, leaving producers to use the label no matter how much or little grass was used in feeding. |
The private {{jfa-highlight | ''American Grass Fed Certified''}} seal also makes dubious claims. This standard requires inspections every 15 months, but can find no evidence the inspections are unannounced—a key provision for meaningful audits. Records of inspections are not public, so we do not know if there are violations or how they are handled. Also, it may be difficult to find products with this seal in your area, More specific claims for this label are discussed below. | The private {{jfa-highlight | ''American Grass Fed Certified''}} seal also makes dubious claims. This standard requires inspections every 15 months, but can find no evidence the inspections are unannounced—a key provision for meaningful audits. Records of inspections are not public, so we do not know if there are violations or how they are handled. Also, it may be difficult to find products with this seal in your area, More specific claims for this label are discussed below. | ||
| Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
—American Grass Fed. The standards for this private certification include a sometimes vaguely worded section on animal welfare and might provide a marginally better life for animals if they were enforced. But the standards neither prohibit nor require anesthetics for routine cruelties such as dehorning and castration. And of course, the animals are sent to slaughter at an early age. | —American Grass Fed. The standards for this private certification include a sometimes vaguely worded section on animal welfare and might provide a marginally better life for animals if they were enforced. But the standards neither prohibit nor require anesthetics for routine cruelties such as dehorning and castration. And of course, the animals are sent to slaughter at an early age. | ||
| + | |||
| + | '''Sustainability Claims.''' | ||
| − | |||
'''Human Health Claims.''' | '''Human Health Claims.''' | ||
| Line 33: | Line 34: | ||
== American Grass-Fed Certified. === | == American Grass-Fed Certified. === | ||
| + | |||
| + | == Research Holding == | ||
'''Generic Grass-Fed Labelling.''' Even before the USDA dropped their regulation of the ''grass-fed'' label in 2016,<ref>USDA Agricultural Marketing Service. “Grass Fed Marketing Claim Standard.” Accessed November 15, 2019. https://www.ams.usda.gov/grades-standards/beef/grassfed. | '''Generic Grass-Fed Labelling.''' Even before the USDA dropped their regulation of the ''grass-fed'' label in 2016,<ref>USDA Agricultural Marketing Service. “Grass Fed Marketing Claim Standard.” Accessed November 15, 2019. https://www.ams.usda.gov/grades-standards/beef/grassfed. | ||
| Line 45: | Line 48: | ||
Regarding {{jfa-highlight | sustainability}}, in the same article Beef Magazine says that " the grain-fed model actually has the smallest footprint."<ref name="beefmag" /> For more information on the sustainability of grass-fed livestock see [https://www.onegreenplanet.org/animalsandnature/why-organic-grass-fed-livestock-is-not-as-sustainable-as-you-might-think/ this article] from One Green Planet our own article on [[Grazing]]. | Regarding {{jfa-highlight | sustainability}}, in the same article Beef Magazine says that " the grain-fed model actually has the smallest footprint."<ref name="beefmag" /> For more information on the sustainability of grass-fed livestock see [https://www.onegreenplanet.org/animalsandnature/why-organic-grass-fed-livestock-is-not-as-sustainable-as-you-might-think/ this article] from One Green Planet our own article on [[Grazing]]. | ||
| − | |||
| − | |||
<!-- | <!-- | ||
Revision as of 12:08, 18 November 2019
Contents
Summary
Animal products packaged with a generic grass-fed label are often thought to represent a better life for animals, a smaller footprint for our planet, and a healthier alternative for human consumption. But as shown below, any claims for animal welfare are meaningless for the generic label, and the claims for sustainability and better health are highly questionable.
In 2016, the USDA stopped regulating the label, leaving producers to use the label no matter how much or little grass was used in feeding.
The private American Grass Fed Certified seal also makes dubious claims. This standard requires inspections every 15 months, but can find no evidence the inspections are unannounced—a key provision for meaningful audits. Records of inspections are not public, so we do not know if there are violations or how they are handled. Also, it may be difficult to find products with this seal in your area, More specific claims for this label are discussed below.
Animal Welfare Claims.
—Generic Label. The label had little implications for animal welfare before the USDA dropped enforcement in 2016, as "most all beef cattle spend at least a portion of their lives on grass," anyway, and no onsite inspection was required. The designation had only to do with feeding. Even when the label was regulated it did not prohibit routine cruelties such as dehorning, castration, harsh living conditions, rough handling, and lack of veterinary care. Now that the label is not regulated it remains meaningless for animal welfare.
—American Grass Fed. The standards for this private certification include a sometimes vaguely worded section on animal welfare and might provide a marginally better life for animals if they were enforced. But the standards neither prohibit nor require anesthetics for routine cruelties such as dehorning and castration. And of course, the animals are sent to slaughter at an early age.
Sustainability Claims.
Human Health Claims.
Generic Label.
Animal Welfare Claims
Now, without even a definition of grass-fed provided by the USDA, producers are free to use the label no matter how much grass an animal has been fed. The designation is virtually meaningless.
Sustainability Claims
Human Health Claims
American Grass-Fed Certified. =
Research Holding
Generic Grass-Fed Labelling. Even before the USDA dropped their regulation of the grass-fed label in 2016,[1] the designation had only to do with feeding and did not prohibit routine cruelties such as dehorning, castration, harsh living conditions, rough handling, and lack of veterinary care. No on-site inspection was required,[2] and animals could still slaughtered at an early age.[3]
Now, without even a definition of grass-fed provided by the USDA, producers are free to use the label no matter how much grass an animal has been fed. The designation is virtually meaningless.
Beef Magazine, the "the beef cattle industry’s authoritative source,"[4] says that "most all beef cattle spend at least a portion of their lives on grass,"[5]. This calls into question the notion that the grass-fed claim confers something special and unique.
In addition to animal welfare claims, two other claims are often made about grass-fed livestock—that they are raised more sustainably and that they are healthier to eat.
Regarding sustainability, in the same article Beef Magazine says that " the grain-fed model actually has the smallest footprint."[5] For more information on the sustainability of grass-fed livestock see this article from One Green Planet our own article on Grazing.
- ↑ USDA Agricultural Marketing Service. “Grass Fed Marketing Claim Standard.” Accessed November 15, 2019. https://www.ams.usda.gov/grades-standards/beef/grassfed.
- ↑ “Labeling Guideline on Documentation Needed to Substantiate Animal Raising Claims for Label Submissions.” USDA FSIS, n.d. https://www.fsis.usda.gov/wps/wcm/connect/bf170761-33e3-4a2d-8f86-940c2698e2c5/Label-Approval-Guide.pdf?MOD=AJPERES
- ↑ Whisnant, DVM, Patricia. “FAQ Grass Fed Beef.” American Grass Fed Beef (blog). Accessed October 25, 2018. https://www.americangrassfedbeef.com/faq-grass-fed-beef.asp
- ↑ Farm Progress Agricultural Marketing. “BEEF.” Accessed November 16, 2019. https://marketing.farmprogress.com/brands/livestock/beef/.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 Beef Magazine. “What’s More Sustainable: Grain-Fed or Grass-Fed Beef?,” December 8, 2016. https://www.beefmagazine.com/agenda/what-s-more-sustainable-grain-fed-or-grass-fed-beef.
